Throughout the day, ABC News' political team contributes to The Note with the very latest news and analysis from the nation's capital.
CONTRIBUTORS
RECENT POSTS
- The Note: Dem-Mentum In The Senate?
- The Note's Must-Reads for Thursday, October 14, 2010
- Opposition to Health Reform Hasn’t Helped Democrats Avoid Tough Races
- Tim Pawlenty Blames ‘Corrosive Impact Of Teachers’ Unions’ For Michelle Rhee's Resignation
- Chris Coons on Christine O’Donnell: ‘She’s Not Me, and She’s Not Delaware’
- Attacks Get Personal in California Gubernatorial Debate
- The Note: ‘Courage’ And Consequences
- The Note's Must-Reads for Wednesday, October 13, 2010
- Bachmann Rakes in $5.4 million in 3rd Quarter
- Democratic Candidate Roy Herron Would Fire Nancy Pelosi As House Speaker
THE NOTE CATEGORIES
- 2010
- 2012
- Ad Watch
- Afghanistan
- Amy Walter
- Amy Walter: Forecast
- Ariane de Vogue
- Arlette Saenz
- Bill Clinton
- Christine O'Donnell
- Christine O’Donnell
- CIA
- Congress
- Connecticut
- Democratic party
- Devin Dwyer
- Environment
- Eric Cantor
- Financial Reform
- George W. Bush
- GOP
- Gov. Mark Sanford
- Gov. Sarah Palin
- Gov. Tim Pawlenty
- Gregory Simmons
- Guantanamo
- Health Care
- Hillary Clinton
- Huma Khan
- Immigration
- Iran
- Iraq
- Joe Biden
- John Boehner
- John McCain
- John Parkinson
- Jonathan Karl
- Karl Rove
- Kathleen Sebelius
- Kirit Radia
- Luis Martinez
- Matthew Jaffe
- Michael Bloomberg
- Michael Falcone
- Michael Steele
- Mitt Romney
- Nancy Pelosi
- Newt Gingrich
- North Korea
- Obama Agenda
- Politics Live
- President Obama
- Republican Party
- Rick Klein
- Ronald Reagan
- Sarah Palin
- Scott Brown
- Sen. John Ensign
- Senate
- Sherisse Pham
- Sonia Sotomayor
- Stimulus
- Sunday Shows
- Supreme Court
- Tahman Bradley
- Tea Party
- Ted Kennedy
- Terry Moran
- The Note
- The Note Must-Reads
- This Week
- Tim Pawlenty
- Timothy Geithner
- Top Line
- Vice President Biden
- Virginia
- West Virginia
- Z. Byron Wolf
MONTHLY ARCHIVES
« Previous | Main | Next »
Attacks Get Personal in California Gubernatorial Debate
October 13, 2010 9:52 AM
ABC News' David Wright reports:
The two candidates for California governor sparred over taxes, illegal immigration, and whether it’s fair game to describe one another as “whores” in their final campaign debate at Dominican College in the San Francisco Bay Area.
The race pits a perennial politician against a billionaire businesswoman. Democrat Jerry Brown is the state’s attorney general, as well as a former governor, a former mayor, and the son of a former governor. Republican Meg Whitman is the former CEO of E-Bay.
Tonight the moderator, former NBC Nightly News anchor Tom Brokaw, held Brown to account for a comment made by one of his aides. After the candidate thought he hung up the phone after leaving a voice mail message for a union leader whose endorsement he sought, one of his aides was overheard suggesting they call Whitman a “whore.”
“We’ve heard no outrage from you,” said Brokaw, noting that the harsh language “to many people is the same as describing an African American using the N-word.”
“I do not agree with that comparison,” Brown said. Some audience members booed.
Whitman pounced. “It’s not just me, it’s the people of California that deserve better than slurs,” she said.
Brown said he’s sorry the incident was made public, suggesting someone broke the law by releasing the recording from a call he made 5 weeks ago.
But Brown did not exactly retract the sentiment behind the word.
Whitman has broken all spending records for a self-financed campaign -- spending more than $120 million out of her own pocket. She defended that largesse, claiming it means she would not be beholden to special interests.
“I am spending my own money in this race,” she said. “But I will not owe anything to anybody.”
But Brown questioned Whitman’s independence, saying she has also raised money from business executives who would benefit from the tax cuts she proposes.
Brokaw also held Whitman to account for her proposal to hold “businesses and households to account” for hiring undocumented workers given that it recently came to light that she employed an illegal immigrant as a nanny and housekeeper for 9 years.
“If you couldn’t tell you were employing an undocumented immigrant in your own home, how can you expect businesses to figure it out?” Brokaw asked.
Whitman insisted she trusted an employment agency to vet the nanny and insisted they employed Nicky Diaz in good faith until the day they learned otherwise. She said businesses need an e-verify program to help them ensure that the workers they employ belong in this country.
Brown dismissed the nanny issue as a “sorry tale,” but couldn’t resist swiping Whitman for employing “foreign serfs” and for not hiring an immigration lawyer to help Diaz when the going got rough.
On some issues the candidates agree. Both oppose Proposition 19, the provision on the November ballot that would essentially legalize marijuana in California.
Both said they continue to support Prop 13, the decades old anti-tax initiative that has held down property taxes for many longtime homeowners while pushing the burden onto newcomers and causing deep problems in the effort to balance the state budget.
Both support the state’s Three Strikes law, the anti-crime measure that imposes mandatory life prison terms for felons convicted of a third felony offense.
Recent polls show Brown slightly ahead of Whitman. But surveys show as many as 20% of the voters are undecided so the race is still up for grabs.
October 13, 2010 in 2010 | Permalink | Share | User Comments (32)
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.
Can California just succede from the Union and save us the trouble.
Posted by: B.S. | Oct 13, 2010 10:01:37 AM
Brown has a dismal fiscal record in Calif. That alone should cause voters to reject him.
The debate itself was disappointing, in that the green party candidate was not permitted to participate.
There goes any real democracy, that anyone thinks they have in this country. The concept is a pure lie.
Posted by: Rick McDaniel | Oct 13, 2010 10:19:12 AM
Tom, I'm really dissapointed that more was not said re: Immigration. Are you slipping, afraid to ask, or NOT ALLOWED to ask, it's really a biggie, don't you think?????????
Posted by: crossman | Oct 13, 2010 11:01:55 AM
Brown is just exactly what we don't need as Gov. He was terrible when he was. To elect him would finish California requiring decades to correct it if at all possible.
Does anyone remember Rose Bird the loon? How about Gov. moon beam.
If you care at all about the state of California vote for Whitman our last chance to stop the madness in our state house.
Posted by: a citizen | Oct 13, 2010 11:07:06 AM
Hey ABC, just how did you PROVE this "one of his aides".... spreading a few lies youself..... it sure sounded like Brown to me....
Posted by: vet1973 | Oct 13, 2010 11:15:56 AM
I would prefer to see Brown in charge.... Wouldnt it be great to see CA go bankrupt with him in charge...
Posted by: vet1973 | Oct 13, 2010 11:18:42 AM
typical Republican hypocrite, hate the illegals, love thier slaves! Thousands of americans hire illegal immigrants, may even get rich from the work these people do but when questioned, they are all against illegal immigration. We have an underclass in America that everyone wants to keep under the carpet. and now we demonized them. We hate them!!! Much more thatn the terrorist of 9/11!! Are we ingrates? is it the reason the world calls us "ugly, stupid americans"?
Posted by: masi | Oct 13, 2010 11:23:15 AM
masi, most people don't hate illegal immigrants, most of us understand their predicament and would probably do the same if need be to feed our families, however, in the scheme of things, it is creating two under class peoples, those who are illegal and those who are legal and vulnerable to those jobs by which illegals employed such as construction, meatpacking, plumbing, painting, drywall, flooring and other once held jobs used by which teenagers needed to assist in supplementing their education to purchase books are spare them from further debt of student loans.
Posted by: phallon | Oct 13, 2010 11:43:26 AM
I love the people critizing whitmean for the illegal worker. Answer me this...Brown is the AG of CA..has he done anything on this case. The women came out pubically and admitted to being in CA illegally and falsfying documents. What will Brown do? My guess..nothing
Posted by: slbmrb | Oct 13, 2010 11:54:30 AM
I think this little so called "leak" about an undocumented worker was a plot born out of the Brown camp to distract voters. When I call Merry Maids to come clean my house I expect Merry Maids to have done a thorough background check of its workers. I don't expect to have to go the extra mile and make all these time consuming calls to make sure the person I hired through a cleaning service is a citizen. It was a stupid attempt by the sorry Jerry Brown to distract voters from the real issue. That California is in the toilet and one flush away from being a welfare state. I don’t mean in the way that California has been a welfare state handing out money like candy for decades. I mean we will need welfare from the feds to keep the state running.
Posted by: Choconet | Oct 13, 2010 11:55:39 AM
Who in the world would vote for Brown, he has lived off the taxpayers for all his life? Is this really what CA wants? If so, you will have made your bed, now lay in it and don't expect taxpayers from other states to bail you out.
Posted by: Freedom | Oct 13, 2010 12:28:27 PM
We are where we are because we have an unqualified Republican governor. We don't need another one. Meg is only out for herself. Ebay was a TOTAL MESS after she took charge. It became about making money for her, not about people being able to sell their stuff. Unless you have a billionaire buffer, you better vote for Jerry. He knows how to be frugal in lean times and has a head on his shoulders. Meg will gut this state and will walk away happily rich and untouched.
Posted by: Codex | Oct 13, 2010 12:29:28 PM
Nine years is a long time to discover the legal status of a slave.I'd say Whitman is just another opportunist. She hates illegals but hires them anyway to do her dirty work.
Posted by: Dave | Oct 13, 2010 12:34:10 PM
To California voters, no other issue should matter than how to keep businesses prospering in their state. Too many are leaving the state because it is over-regulated and overtaxing to businesses. Unemployment is high because businesses are leaving and/or closing. The schools are losing money because the state is losing its economic base.
One candidate understands the loops that businesses go through to operate in California. The other candidate has no comprehension of what it takes to make a business successful. I don't live in California, but if I did, I'd put party politics aside on this one and go with the candidate who might have some insight as to how to bring businesses back into California, because if that happens, the other issues - unemployment, school funding, etc., will work themselves out.
Posted by: Me | Oct 13, 2010 12:45:24 PM
Vote this woman in and you send the message to the world that America can be bought by billionaires. It's just that simple. With her winning we begin to take a slide that we never saw coming.
Posted by: secondlook | Oct 13, 2010 12:52:29 PM
so 120mil of her own money will surely BUY her the election, this is gettig really old fast...
Posted by: dlj | Oct 13, 2010 1:14:51 PM
Jerry Brown already gave over 6 million CA voters the finger when he refused to do his job and defend prop 8 in court. He doesn't deserve his current position, let alone to be governer.
However, sadly, in the end, this state is so screwed up that regardless of who we elect, it may not do much to fix things here in CA.
Posted by: J.R. | Oct 13, 2010 1:32:51 PM
I keep seeing in posts where people refer to illegal immigrant workers as "slaves". This is an extremely poor comparison. I the illegal immigrant does not not receiving a paycheck or the work they are doing, then they can pack their bag and head back across the border!
Posted by: Brian | Oct 13, 2010 1:41:23 PM
at least California gets a debate!In Texas the incumbent Rick Perry (R) will not only NOT debate,he won't talk to reporter,nor can anyone that lives here ask a question of him,and he only will give a speech before a carefully vetted audience of ONLY Republican supporters,and his current gripe with Washington these days is no more fedral money to rebuild millionaires homes on the gulf,but all along stating "that we don't need Washington down here."
Posted by: a sane txn | Oct 13, 2010 1:43:48 PM
Enough with these super rich people trying to buy an election. And she spent away too much on negative adds. Clearly, she set the tone in this election. We hardly heard from Brown until September. Now she'e weeping about trashing her.
We in California are eying the rich for tax increases. No doubt, she will squash that if elected. NO ONE gets rich on their own. And we went to war and they got a tax break. Time for them to pay up. Class warfare? You bet. It's been going on for years and we're losing!
Posted by: Tim | Oct 13, 2010 2:00:15 PM
Post a comment
POLITICAL VIDEOS
THE NOTE BLOG ROLL
- ABC News -- George Stephanopoulos
- ABC News -- Jake Tapper
- ABC News Politics
- ABC News -- The Numbers
- ABC News -- The Blotter
- The American Prospect -- TAPPED
- The Atlantic -- Politics Channel
- The Boston Globe -- Political Intelligence
- Center for American Progress -- Think Progress
- Center for Responsive Politics
- The Chicago Sun-Times -- Lynn Sweet
- The Chicago Tribune -- The Swamp
- Drudge Report
- FactCheck.org
- FiveThirtyEight
- Heritage Foundation -- The Foundry
- The Hill -- Briefing Room
- The Hotline
- The Huffington Post
- The Los Angeles Times -- Top of the Ticket
- NPR -- Political Junkie
- National Review -- The Corner
- The New Republic -- The Plank
- The New York Times -- The Caucus
- Newsweek -- The Gaggle
- Political Wire -- Taegan Goddard
- Politico -- Ben Smith
- Politico -- Mike Allen’s Playbook
- PolitiFact
- Real Clear Politics
- Talking Points Memo
- Time -- The Page
- USA Today -- On Politics
- Variety -- Wilshire & Washington
- The Wall Street Journal -- Capital Journal
- The Washington Post -- The Fix
- The Washington Post -- 44
